Ethical Considerations of Emirates Airline UAE Visa Service - David Osaghae

Emirates has introduced a transit visa option for Nigerian travelers flying to Dubai, aiming to simplify travel and position Dubai as an appealing stopover destination. However, this initiative raises important questions regarding its compliance with UN migration guidelines and IATA/ICAO competition laws, particularly in light of the increasing presence of Nigerian airline Air Peace, which now offers routes to the UAE.

While the transit visa program is designed to enhance customer convenience and experience, it also raises ethical concerns about adherence to fair migration practices outlined by the UN. The exclusive nature of the transit visa—reportedly yielding the highest success rate for Emirates passengers—potentially limits access for travelers using other airlines, calling into question its alignment with the principle of equitable travel access.

In light of global aviation standards established by organizations like the International Air Transport Association (IATA) and the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), such exclusive visa arrangements may conflict with principles encouraging open competition and fair access within the aviation industry. IATA and ICAO laws emphasize transparency and non-discrimination, advocating that all travelers should have fair access to entry options and transit visas, regardless of their airline choice.

There is also speculation as to whether this move reflects broader UAE efforts to manage competition within the aviation sector, particularly with the expansion of Nigerian carriers like Air Peace on the Dubai route. This raises concerns about whether such policies indirectly create barriers for other airlines, potentially impacting fair market competition. Balancing customer service initiatives with adherence to international fair access principles will be essential to addressing these ethical and legal considerations.

Certainly. When national carriers or any airline are perceived to have an unfair advantage in a country, especially regarding exclusive visa privileges, it can raise concerns under several IATA and ICAO regulations that emphasize fair competition, non-discrimination, and open access in the aviation industry. Here’s a closer look at relevant laws and guidelines:

David Osaghae, CEO, Afari Travels & Tours

1. ICAO’s Convention on International Civil Aviation (Chicago Convention), Article 44:

The objectives of ICAO under Article 44 of the Chicago Convention include promoting the safe and orderly growth of international civil aviation throughout the world. It explicitly advocates for “avoiding discrimination between contracting states.”
Implication: Granting exclusive transit visa privileges to passengers of one specific airline, especially a national carrier, could be seen as discriminatory. This might violate ICAO’s principle of ensuring that international civil aviation operates in a fair and non-discriminatory manner.

2. ICAO Policies on Competition in International Air Transport (Doc 9587):

This document emphasizes fair competition among airlines and discourages practices that could be construed as anti-competitive or protectionist. ICAO encourages states to consider “the interests of all carriers” to ensure an open and competitive air transport environment.
Implication: Favoring a national airline with exclusive visa privileges might limit competition by disadvantaging foreign carriers, potentially discouraging competition and limiting passenger choice. This could be viewed as a violation of ICAO’s competition policies.

3. IATA’s Principles on Liberalization and Fair Competition:

IATA advocates for the liberalization of air transport markets, meaning that market access should be open and not unduly restricted. IATA also opposes state actions that confer artificial advantages on national airlines to the detriment of foreign carriers.
Implication: Exclusive transit visa offerings for one airline could be interpreted as a restriction on market access, particularly if it incentivizes passengers to favor one carrier over others due to visa accessibility, creating an uneven playing field.

4. WTO General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS) – Air Transport Annex:

Though not directly enforced by ICAO or IATA, the WTO’s GATS agreement applies to services in air transport. GATS prohibits discriminatory treatment and supports equal access in service sectors, including aviation.
Implication: By favoring Emirates with exclusive visa privileges, the UAE may contravene GATS principles on fair access for all service providers, potentially impacting other airlines like Nigeria’s Air Peace.

5. ICAO’s Guidance on State Aid and Market Distortion (Doc 9626):

This ICAO guidance discourages state support or policies that could distort competition within the international aviation market.
Implication: If Emirates is granted exclusive rights that other airlines cannot access, it may raise concerns of state aid or preferential treatment that distorts competition. This could be considered a form of indirect state support, which ICAO discourages unless it complies with international competitive standards.

The primary Nigerian airline that operates routes to the UAE is Air Peace. Air Peace launched its direct flights between Lagos (LOS) and Sharjah (SHJ) in July 2019, marking a significant milestone as the first Nigerian airline to fly to the UAE. Here’s an overview:

1. Air Peace: Lagos to Sharjah

Route: Lagos (LOS) to Sharjah (SHJ)
Flight Frequency: Typically a few flights per week, though frequencies may vary depending on demand and season.
Connection to Dubai: Sharjah is about a 30-minute drive from Dubai, making it a convenient entry point for travelers heading to Dubai or other areas in the UAE.

Key Considerations:

Competitive Market: Air Peace’s Lagos-Sharjah route provides Nigerian travelers an alternative to international carriers like Emirates and Qatar Airways, which offer direct flights to Dubai and Abu Dhabi, respectively.
Expansion Plans: Air Peace has shown interest in expanding its international routes, and depending on demand and regulatory permissions, additional routes to the UAE or other Gulf countries may be possible in the future.

Emirates and other Gulf-based airlines dominate the Nigeria-UAE route, but Air Peace’s service to Sharjah represents a Nigerian-owned option, offering more choice for travelers between the two countries.

In summary, both ICAO and IATA guidelines emphasize the need for fair and non-discriminatory access in air transport services. Policies that appear to benefit a national carrier over others could conflict with these principles, as they may limit competition and restrict equal access for other airlines.

Post Views: 65